For somebody eating Louisiana king cake for the first time, finding a tiny plastic baby in a slice can raise an obvious question.
Why exactly is there a baby in the cake?
The short answer is that the baby is the modern Louisiana version of a much older tradition of hiding a small object inside an Epiphany cake. The object once might have been a bean, coin, charm, nut, or porcelain figurine. Whoever found it received a special role in the celebration.
In Louisiana, that centuries-old custom eventually evolved into the familiar king cake baby.
Today, the baby is commonly understood to represent the infant Jesus, fitting the cake’s connection to Epiphany and the visit of the Magi. But the history is more complicated than simply saying that bakers have always hidden a baby Jesus in the cake.
They haven’t.
The baby came later.
The Tradition Started with a Hidden Favor
Long before plastic babies appeared in Louisiana bakeries, European Epiphany cakes commonly contained a hidden object.
King cake is associated with January 6, the Feast of the Epiphany, which in Christian tradition commemorates the visit of the Magi, or Three Kings, to the infant Jesus. European cultures developed their own cakes for the celebration, including France’s galette des rois, Spain’s roscón de reyes, Britain’s Twelfth Cake, and related traditions elsewhere.
What went inside those cakes varied.
A bean might be hidden in one. Another could contain a coin, piece of candy, charm, nut, or small porcelain figure. The person whose slice contained the hidden object might be declared king or queen of the gathering.
That basic idea—the cake selecting someone—is older than Louisiana’s modern king cake baby.
The baby belongs to a much longer family of hidden favors.
Louisiana Originally Used Beans Too
When the king cake tradition developed in Louisiana, the hidden object was not necessarily a baby.
One of the best-known examples comes from the Twelfth Night Revelers, an early New Orleans Carnival organization.
At an 1871 ball, the Revelers served a cake containing a gold bean and several silver beans. Emma Butler received the gold bean and became the celebration’s queen, while the silver beans helped identify members of her court.
The tradition continued in forms that survive to this day. Explore Louisiana describes the Twelfth Night Revelers’ modern ceremony as using a golden bean to select a queen while silver beans identify her maids.
So the hidden-object tradition was firmly established in New Orleans Carnival culture before the little plastic baby became standard.
The Baby Fits the Meaning of Epiphany
The modern king cake baby is commonly understood to represent the infant Jesus.
That makes sense within the Christian meaning of Epiphany.
January 6 commemorates the Magi finding the Christ child, and the Carnival season in Louisiana traditionally begins on that date. A tiny child hidden within the cake therefore became a natural symbol for a celebration centered on the Three Kings’ search for Jesus.
But there is an important distinction.
The symbolism of the baby is connected to the Christ child.
The practice of hiding something inside the cake is older and historically included many objects other than babies.
Louisiana eventually brought those two ideas together.
Before Plastic, There Were Porcelain Figures
The transition from beans and other favors to baby figurines appears to have developed through twentieth-century New Orleans bakery culture.
The former McKenzie’s Pastry Shoppes are especially associated with that change.
McKenzie’s became one of New Orleans’s best-known bakery chains and a major producer of king cakes. Accounts of exactly when figurines first appeared vary somewhat, but food historians and members of the bakery’s founding family connect McKenzie’s with the popularization of small dolls in king cakes.
New Orleans food historian Poppy Tooker told NPR that baker Donald Entringer encountered a traveling salesman who had a supply of small porcelain dolls. Entringer began using them as king cake favors, and when that supply ran out, he eventually obtained small plastic babies.
A WYES history of McKenzie’s also connects the Entringer family with the development of the bakery’s famous king cake and remembers a progression that included beans, dolls, and eventually the plastic baby.
The exact timeline differs depending on the account.
What is much clearer is the result.
By the 1960s, plastic babies had become the norm in Louisiana king cakes.
Why Plastic Babies Became So Common
Plastic had some obvious advantages over porcelain.
It was inexpensive, lightweight, readily available, and much harder to break.
That mattered once king cakes moved beyond small household celebrations and became a major commercial bakery product.
By the middle of the twentieth century, New Orleans bakeries were producing large numbers of cakes throughout Carnival season. A small, standardized plastic baby was an easy favor to include with each one.
Eventually, the plastic baby became so recognizable that many people began assuming it had always been part of king cake.
It hadn’t.
Louisiana had simply found a modern object that fit an old tradition unusually well.
What Happens If You Find the Baby?
Finding the baby usually comes with two things:
honor and responsibility.
Traditionally, the hidden favor identified the king or queen of the celebration.
Louisiana kept that idea but added another custom: the person who finds the baby is commonly expected to provide the next king cake or host the next king cake gathering.
That rule helps explain why king cake works so well as a Carnival tradition.
One cake leads to another.
A family has one on Twelfth Night. Someone gets the baby and brings the next cake. Then another person finds it. The process can continue through offices, classrooms, neighborhood gatherings, clubs, and family parties until Mardi Gras.
The tiny favor keeps the social tradition moving.
Finding the baby might make you royalty for a moment.
It can also make you the person making a bakery run next week.
Is Finding the Baby Good Luck?
Many people consider finding the baby good luck.
That idea fits the much older tradition in which the person receiving the hidden favor was singled out for special status.
In Louisiana, however, the meaning often depends more on family or group custom than on any fixed rule.
Some people treat finding the baby as lucky.
Some crown the finder king or queen.
Some say the finder must host the next gathering.
Others skip the royalty altogether and go straight to the important part:
You’re buying the next cake.
Like many Louisiana traditions, the details can vary while the basic custom remains recognizable.
Is the Baby Baked Inside the Cake?
Not always.
Older generations of Louisianians may remember buying king cakes with the baby already baked or inserted inside.
Many modern bakeries instead provide the plastic baby separately, allowing the customer to insert it into the finished cake before serving. NPR reported that bakeries increasingly moved away from baking the plastic figurine directly into the cake, while Explore Louisiana describes today’s small plastic baby as being tucked inside the cake.
Practices vary by bakery.
Regardless of how it gets there, anyone serving king cake should make sure guests know that a small nonfood object may be hidden inside.
That is especially important for children and anyone unfamiliar with the tradition.
King cake is supposed to produce a little Carnival excitement—not an emergency trip to the dentist.
Are Babies the Only King Cake Favor?
No.
Historically, king cakes have contained many different kinds of favors.
Beans are among the oldest and most famous. New Orleans Carnival traditions have also included pecans, rings, coins, charms, porcelain figures, and other objects.
Even today, some bakeries use distinctive collectible figurines rather than the most familiar generic plastic baby.
That variation is completely consistent with king cake history.
The tradition has never depended on one exact object.
The important idea is that something is hidden and someone finds it.
The Baby Is Both Religious and Social
The king cake baby works on two levels.
On one level, it reflects the cake’s connection with Epiphany. The tiny child is commonly interpreted as the Christ child sought by the Three Kings.
On another level, it performs the same job as the old bean or charm.
It chooses someone.
That person becomes part of the ritual and, in Louisiana, usually inherits responsibility for continuing it.
That combination helps explain why the baby endured.
It connects the modern Louisiana cake with both the religious story behind King’s Day and the playful social tradition of choosing a king or queen from the people gathered around the table.
From Bean to Baby
The story of the king cake baby is really a story about how food traditions evolve.
Louisiana did not invent the idea of hiding an object inside an Epiphany cake. European traditions had been doing that for centuries.
Louisiana inherited the practice and changed it.
Beans helped choose Carnival royalty in nineteenth-century New Orleans. Other favors appeared. Porcelain figures became associated with commercial king cakes. Plastic babies followed and became commonplace by the 1960s.
Today, someone cutting into a Louisiana king cake may discover a little plastic baby instead of a bean.
The object changed.
The basic idea did not.
One person finds the favor, becomes the center of attention for a moment, and helps make sure there will be another cake.
For something so small, that baby has a pretty big job.
Explore Louisiana Food with EatBayou
EatBayou is building a statewide guide to Louisiana food, cooking traditions, and restaurants.
Explore Louisiana dishes, learn how regional and family traditions differ, and discover locally owned food businesses serving the foods that make the state distinctive.
Suggest a restaurant for a free listing, or advertise with EatBayou to reach people looking for Louisiana food.